October 21, 2003
CHARLESTON, South Carolina — The former spiritual leader of the world's Anglicans urged the
first openly gay bishop-elect in the Episcopal Church to step down
before his consecration next month.
But Dr. George Carey, who retired as archbishop of Canterbury last October, also said he hoped no one would split from the Anglican Communion over the Rev. V. Gene Robinson of New Hampshire.
"I strongly resist a realignment of the communion," Carey said, in a speech Sunday at a church in Charleston. He traveled to South Carolina to lead a clergy retreat there this week.
The 77-million-member Anglican Communion, represented by the Episcopal Church in the United States, has been debating homosexuality for years. But the issue erupted after the Diocese of New Hampshire elected Robinson in June and national Episcopal leaders confirmed him in August.
Robinson, a divorced father of two, has been living with his
male partner since 1989. Some of the 38 Anglican leaders, called
primates, have threatened to sever ties with the Episcopal Church
over his election. A group of U.S. conservatives is also moving
toward a break with the church.
The current archbishop of Canterbury, the Most Rev. Rowan
Williams, summoned the primates to an emergency meeting on the
issue last week in London. They collectively issued a statement
warning that Robinson's consecration Nov. 2 could "tear the fabric"
of the communion.
Carey noted that Robinson's election had disrupted Anglican
relations with other denominations. Pope John Paul II told Williams
this month that it has caused "serious difficulties" in efforts to
unify the Roman Catholic and Anglican churches. Carey called the
situation an "ecumenical scandal."
He said the communion has always been known for diversity, held
together by a common liturgy while accepting a variety of
theological opinions, but Scripture has always been recognized as
the highest authority. In 1998, Anglican bishops approved a
resolution saying that gay sex violates Scripture. Carey said the
primates need to continue to work together to come up with ways to
discipline members who step out of line.
The same day that Carey spoke, Robinson addressed parishioners
in New Hampshire, saying the bitter church debate over
homosexuality would continue whether or not he gave up leadership
of the diocese.
"It's not all going to go back to being nice and pretty again.
It's going to be messy for a while," Robinson said. "This is not
our church to win or lose. It's God's church." – Sapa-AP
US Episcopals divided over homosexuality
Anglican leaders call for commission on homosexuality
Statement from 37 Anglican leaders on gay crisis
Senior African cleric rallies to gay Anglican cause
Anglican leader under pressure to repudiate gay-friendly moves in the US
British Anglicans support gay clergy: poll
Aus Anglicans want expulsion of liberal Americansover gay marriages