Video games: online consoles soar while PCs stumble
April 8, 2004
AUSTIN, Texas April — Only a few years ago, online games still lurked on the fringe of
One category catered to young males interested in wreaking havoc
- at others' expense. And then there were the complex, virtual
communities that more closely mirror the real world in their social
Today, those never-ending online "massively multiplayer" games
like "EverQuest" have matured into mainstream, vibrant attractions,
drawing hundreds of thousands of paying customers - male and
But their growth appears almost stagnant compared to the
popularity spike for multiplayer online shoot'em-ups and other
mostly war-themed fare geared toward users of console systems, led
by Sony Corp.'s Playstation2 and Microsoft Corp.'s Xbox.
Already this year, two "persistent" fantasy world online
computer games have been scrapped, one before it even made it to
Broadband Internet access, meanwhile, has helped bring
connectivity to consoles that wasn't even an option two years ago.
Now, 750,000 players use Xbox Live, each paying $50 a year to be
able to play against people elsewhere and download updates.
Sony says it has sold 2.4 million of its $40 network adapters
that enable Playstation online gaming, through broadband or a
By 2008, 40.2 million gamers worldwide will be going online with
video game consoles, says market research firm DFC Intelligence.
"There's no denying that this is the next level of game play,"
NPD analyst Richard Ow said. "The console business is all about
Nearly 50 games with some sort of online feature have been
released for the Playstation2 in the past year, and twice that
number are planned by year's end. Microsoft expects about 100 games
using Xbox Live in stores by May.
"It sort of has become an expected feature," said Seth Luisi,
senior producer of the military shoot-'em-up game "SOCOM II: U.S.
Navy SEALs" for the Playstation2. Of the 920,000 copies sold, about
half are being played online, Luisi said.
Troubles in the land of persistent online worlds, meanwhile,
surfaced in February, when the multiplayer feature of the adventure
game "URU: Ages Beyond Myst" was canceled.
Before its December launch, creator Rand Miller speculated that
at least 100,000 subscribers - each paying between $10 to $15 a
month - would be the sustenance required for "URU Live" to succeed.
The number of initial subscribers was never released.
Weeks later, Microsoft canned a Norse mythology online game in
development called "Mythica" after what the company described as a
"careful evaluation of the MMORPG (massively multiplayer online
role-playing game) landscape."
Despite a $300 million investment, "The Sims Online" from
Electronic Arts Inc. only has about 80,000 subscribers more than a
year after its release, far short of the company's stated goal of 1
The bar is higher for persistent games because they require a
deeper time investment than console games, said Sony Online
Entertainment spokesman Chris Kramer. The company debuted the
medieval fantasy game "EverQuest" five years ago.
"You can't jump into the massively multiplayer space the same
way that you can into a regular single-player game," Kramer said.
"You have a game where the strength of the game is relying on
people to come back to it. No one is going to want to give you $13
a month for `just OK."'
Massively multiplayer games have no such problems in countries
such as South Korea, where a high percentage of homes have
broadband Internet connections and millions of gamers play online.
Korean-based "Ragnarok Online," for example, boasts 17 million
users worldwide in a game where players can battle, chat or obtain
In the United States, PC games like the futuristic battle game
"Unreal Tournament 2004" are quite popular with people who want to
blast each other online. But those games are free to play.
By comparison, most MMORPGS charge monthly fees in addition to
upfront hardware and software costs.Alan Cates, a 55-year-old
Internet marketing consultant and gamer from California thinks
online PC games are better if they appeal to both hardcore and
"It seems to be a problem for the game designer. What do they do
with those that spend 100 hours a week playing the game and those
that spend four hours a month?" Cates said.
For the genre to really reach the masses, online games need to
broaden their appeal beyond males between 15 and 25, said Sheri
Graner Ray, a game designer with Sony Online.
"The market is not growing as fast as the game industry. It
means we've got to expand our market to attract more women," she
said this month at the South by Southwest interactive festival.
"It's not about making games with fluffy pink kitties. It's about
understanding what barriers are out there preventing females from
accessing games today."
At the electronic hangout "There," users pay $5 a month to chat,
buy and sell virtual items and drive dune buggies. It has gained
tens of thousands of players since it launched in October. Its
creator, There Inc., won't say how many subscribers There has but
notes that nearly half the users are women and 55 percent are over
At Electronic Arts, spokeswoman Susan Lusty said the market for
massively multiplayer online role-playing games is still in the
"It's a matter of figuring out the perfect blend of financials
and game play that will really propel this style of game play
forward," she said.
Most big multiplayer games in the works don't appear to be
moving very far from the young male demographic.
Blizzard Entertainment, part of Vivendi Universal SA, plans to
launch a persistent online game called "World of Warcraft" this
year. South Korean-based NCsoft Corp., meanwhile, is putting the
final touches on "Lineage II" - a sequel to "Lineage: The Blood
Pledge," one of the most popular online games ever.
The swords and sorcery of "EverQuest" return too, with
"EverQuest II" due in the fall. –Sapa-AP
Related links stories
George Michael to put future songs on internet, for free [12/03/2004]